Яндекс.Метрика
Home » Materials » Charisma and "Politics of Proximity" in the time of the Revolution and Civil War

Charisma and "Politics of Proximity" in the time of the Revolution and Civil War

Scientific E-journal «edu.e-history.kz» № 1

Charisma and "Politics of Proximity" in the time of the Revolution and Civil War
Author:
Annotation As it radically alters the arrangement of social forces, the Revolution fosters the emergence of new power paradigms distinct from those dominant in the time of relative calm. In particular, the material infrastructural disintegration is often accompanied by the refutation of the bureaucratic authority (in Weberian sense) and the subsequent replacement thereof with the system of power relations designated by the author as the "politics of proximity."
Text:
Annotation As it radically alters the arrangement of social forces, the Revolution fosters the emergence of new power paradigms distinct from those dominant in the time of relative calm. In particular, the material infrastructural disintegration is often accompanied by the refutation of the bureaucratic authority (in Weberian sense) and the subsequent replacement thereof with the system of power relations designated by the author as the "politics of proximity." In such circumstances, the individual charisma begins to play an increasingly important role, evolving not only into a symbol of the "revolutionary immediacy" (as opposed to bureaucratic mediation), but also into a factor with a power to shape the form of the political modus operandi in the post-revolutionary period. Key Terms: Revolution, charismatic authority, bureaucratic authority, Civil War, personality cult Charisma and the Politics of Proximity: Case of Nestor Makhno The collapse of the Russian state could be narrated, analyzed and interpreted from a whole bevy of perspectives. One approach, no doubt among the dominant ones, places emphasis on the material aspects of this collapse, that is, on the growing wear and tear of the sinews that held the Imperial state once together – army, bureaucratic apparatus, means of communication, etc. The concept of razrukha – a hybrid of ruin and chaos – employed with a near pathological insistence by the contemporaries of all political colors in describing the post-Revolutionary reality, adverts to the concomitant effects of the said „material‟ deterioration. A soldier leaving his position with a triokhlineika rifle on his shoulder strap; a middle-level district bureaucrat gaping aghast at the dilapidated and hence desecrated „seat‟ of his former power; an ammunition factory, no longer animated by the din of continuous work, but rather by the clamor of workers calling for higher wages and shorter hours, loud at first, then subsiding and petering out into the terrible still; a letter sent but never delivered; the profusion of superannuated newspapers, suitable only to proffer the solace of evanescent warmth; septic wagons of the trains, journeying at the rate that gave full temporal dimension to the eternity of Russian spatial expanses – all of these tropes constitute, metonymically if one so wills, the body and spirit of the Russian Civil War. With the restraining forces once overcome, the entropy tended to increase untill the Bolsheviks, actively or passively assisted by the populace, temporarily ended a moratorium on revolutionary experiments and successfully restored the state apparatus towards whose destruction they had been known to work with an enviable diligence and animation. The use of the vision, centered on the changes in the infrastructure, raises few objections. The half-sinusoidal curve of disintegration and restoration marks out the framework within which a plethora of phenomena appear intellectually tangible; to wit, one feels oneself adequately equipped when venturing to explain why it had been easier to obtain monopolistic control over the remaining instruments of power in some peripheral regions of the fallen empire than in others, and thus to shield incipient national projects against the encroachments of the Bolshevik-controlled center. On the level of ideology, the fragmentation of what once had been a uniform informational field into an archipelago of isolated isles, impervious to the news from without and highly resistant to the pressures from within – that development stands in an intimate and direct rapport with the outpouring of fantasies and rumors, tingeing the notion of Bolshevism with the hues of local preferences. Such diverse political revelations as the peasant republic in Ukraine‟s Medvyn, the brutal comic opera of Baron von Ungern‟s neo-Genghisid empire, the Cossack Don and Kuban autonomies and Polish expansionist ambitions are brought closer, if not through a community of a cause, but through a commonwealth of a narrative sentiment.

No comments

To leave comment you must enter or register

Views: 4791

No reviews

Download files

Category

Interdisciplinary studies Methodological works Macro- and Microhistory History of the Homeland. New research methods Research works of  young scientists Review. Comment

Related articles

Author's articles

Солтүстік Каспий аймағының түркілену процесі Бірінші дүние жүзілік соғыс тұтқындары Жетісуда Charisma and "Politics of Proximity" in the time of the Revolution and Civil War Роль военной контрразведки «Смерш» в годы Великой Отечественной войны и подвиг нашего земляка ҚАЗАҚСТАН МЕН ҚЫТАЙ АРАСЫНДАҒЫ ШЕКАРАЛЫҚ КЕЛІССӨЗДЕР МӘСЕЛЕСІ Абд ар-Раззак Самаркандидің «Матла ' ас-са ' дайн ва маджма 'ал-бахрайны» шығармасы ХАЛЫҚТАРДЫ КҮШТЕП ҚОНЫС АУДАРУ – АҚМОЛА ОБЛЫСЫНДА ПОЛИЭТНИКАЛЫҚ ХАЛЫҚТЫҢ ҚАЛЫПТАСУЫНЫҢ БІР ФАКТОРЫ РЕТІНДЕ МРНТИ 3.20.00 DOI 10.51943/2710_3994_2021_1_1 ОCНОВНЫЕ АCПЕКТЫ РОCCИЙCКО – КАЗАХCТАНCКОГО ВЗАИМОДЕЙCТВИЯ В ТАМОЖЕННОЙ CФЕРЕ «edu.e-history.kz электронды журналы 4(28), 2021 «edu.e-history.kz» электрондық ғылыми журнал 3(27), 2021 «edu.e-history.kz» электрондық ғылыми журнал 1(29), 2022 ЯЗЫКИ И КУЛЬТУРЫ ПРЕДСТАВИТЕЛЕЙ ОСНОВНЫХ ЭТНОСОВ КАЗАХСТАНА ЧЕРЕЗ ПРИЗМУ КАЗАХСТАНСКОЙ МОДЕЛИ МЕЖЭТНИЧЕСКОГО СОГЛАСИЯ ШЫҒЫС ҚАЗАҚСТАНДАҒЫ ЭТНОДЕМОГРАФИЯЛЫҚ ҮДЕРІСТЕРДІҢ КЕЙБІР МӘСЕЛЕЛЕРІ (ХХ ғ. 20-30 жж.) О ДВУХ ЭТАПАХ ИСТОРИИ БУДДИЗМА В ЮГО-ВОСТОЧНОМ КАЗАХСТАНЕ ДОМОНГОЛЬСКОГО ПЕРИОДА МОБИЛИЗАЦИЯ ЛЮДСКИХ И МАТЕРИАЛЬНЫХ РЕСУРСОВ КАЗАХСТАНА НА ОБОРОНУ СССР АҚТӨБЕ ОБЛЫСЫНДАҒЫ ПОЛЯКТАРДЫҢ ҚУҒЫН-СҮРГІНГЕ ҰШЫРАУ ТАРИХЫ ОТАНДЫҚ ТАРИХШЫЛАРДЫҢ ҚАЗАҚСТАНДАҒЫ АСА МАҢЫЗДЫ ТАРИХИ ТҰЛҒАЛАРДЫ ҚАБЫЛДАУЫ МЕН БАҒАЛАУЫ (ӘЛЕУМЕТТІК ЗЕРТТЕУ НӘТИЖЕЛЕРІ БОЙЫНША) БАТЫС ҚАЗАҚСТАНДАҒЫ КЕЙІНГІ САРМАТ МӘДЕНИЕТІНЕ ТӘН ЖЕРЛЕУ ҒҰРПЫ ӘЛИХАН БӨКЕЙХАН, АХМЕТ БАЙТҰРСЫНҰЛЫ ЖӘНЕ «ҚАЗАҚ» ГАЗЕТІНІҢ ФЕНОМЕНІ THE REPRESSIVE POLICY OF THE SOVIET GOVERNMENT TOWARDS EUROPEAN EMIGRANTS АКАДЕМИК МАНАШ ҚОЗЫБАЕВ ЖӘНЕ ЭТНОС ТАРИХЫНЫҢ ГЕНЕЗИСТІК МӘСЕЛЕЛЕРІ КЕҢЕСТІК БИЛІКТІҢ ҚАЗАҚСТАНДАҒЫ МЕШІТТЕРГЕ ҚАРСЫ САЯСАТЫ (1918-1953 жж.) «ШЕЖІРЕ-И-ТАРАКИМЕ» ШЫҒАРМАСЫНДАҒЫ АУЫЗША ТАРИХ ДӘСТҮРІ: ДЕРЕКТЕМЕЛІК ТАЛДАУ ЖӘНЕ ТӘПСІРЛЕУ МӘСЕЛЕЛЕРІ